
- Strange-Track-Legs
- 01-22-2007
If you were Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
This question has troubled me for years now, but I've never had time to dig
into it. Can someone please tell me what is happening?
I have a Garmin 12Map. I routinely save track logs, especially when
traveling in new places. I use the "Fill", not "Wrap", option. On the
last trip, for example, I saved seven full track logs.
What is strange, is that periodically I get an inexplicable track leg,
sometimes several hundred miles long, between two places that I have been,
(or sometimes where I haven't even been). This track leg is straight, and
there aren't even any roads there, so it is impossible to have traveled it.
However, otherwise, the actual track(s) that were followed appear to be
accurate.
These straight line "track legs" appear not only on the 12Map screen, but
also on a MapSource World Map display.
Can someone please explain what causes this, and/or tell me if I am doing
something wrong?
Thank you very much,
David
David wrote:
I take it you are saving these tracks on the unit itself. There are a
few differences between such "Saved" tracks and the one "Active Log"
track:
1) they are compressed to a smaller number of points so some accuracy
is lost;
2) they lack the time/datestamp data;
3) they don't have the ability to display discontinuous tracks.
I believe you're seeing the result of the third characteristic. Say I
go for a walk in Chicago and have the tracklog recording. I then turn
off the GPS and catch a train to Milwaukee. The next morning I turn on
the GPS and it acquires a lock in the new location and shortly
thereafter I "save" the tracklog on the unit. The original "Active
Log" would have correctly shown my walk around Chicago and then a few
points in my Milwaukee location. But the "Saved" log can't correctly
show the gap so it includes a straight line from the last location in
Chicago to the first one in Milwaukee.
Also note that sometimes when the unit is first turned on it may
momentarily compute an incorrect location when it is receiving a
limited number of satellites and one of the signals might be a
reflected one or have some other error - this could also result in a
long line appearing between that initial false position and the later
correct one.
If you have downloaded a recent upgrade to the MapSource program it
should include some new tools for editing tracklogs. You can use these
to split your Saved tracks and eliminate the spurious straight line
segments.
>I take it you are saving these tracks on the unit itself. There are a
>few differences between such "Saved" tracks and the one "Active Log"
>track:
>1) they are compressed to a smaller number of points so some accuracy
>is lost;
>2) they lack the time/datestamp data;
>3) they don't have the ability to display discontinuous tracks.
>I believe you're seeing the result of the third characteristic. Say I
>go for a walk in Chicago and have the tracklog recording. I then turn
>off the GPS and catch a train to Milwaukee. The next morning I turn on
>the GPS and it acquires a lock in the new location and shortly
>thereafter I "save" the tracklog on the unit. The original "Active
>Log" would have correctly shown my walk around Chicago and then a few
>points in my Milwaukee location. But the "Saved" log can't correctly
>show the gap so it includes a straight line from the last location in
>Chicago to the first one in Milwaukee.
>Also note that sometimes when the unit is first turned on it may
>momentarily compute an incorrect location when it is receiving a
>limited number of satellites and one of the signals might be a
>reflected one or have some other error - this could also result in a
>long line appearing between that initial false position and the later
>correct one.
>If you have downloaded a recent upgrade to the MapSource program it
>should include some new tools for editing tracklogs. You can use these
>to split your Saved tracks and eliminate the spurious straight line
>segments.
>few differences between such "Saved" tracks and the one "Active Log"
>track:
>1) they are compressed to a smaller number of points so some accuracy
>is lost;
>2) they lack the time/datestamp data;
>3) they don't have the ability to display discontinuous tracks.
>I believe you're seeing the result of the third characteristic. Say I
>go for a walk in Chicago and have the tracklog recording. I then turn
>off the GPS and catch a train to Milwaukee. The next morning I turn on
>the GPS and it acquires a lock in the new location and shortly
>thereafter I "save" the tracklog on the unit. The original "Active
>Log" would have correctly shown my walk around Chicago and then a few
>points in my Milwaukee location. But the "Saved" log can't correctly
>show the gap so it includes a straight line from the last location in
>Chicago to the first one in Milwaukee.
>Also note that sometimes when the unit is first turned on it may
>momentarily compute an incorrect location when it is receiving a
>limited number of satellites and one of the signals might be a
>reflected one or have some other error - this could also result in a
>long line appearing between that initial false position and the later
>correct one.
>If you have downloaded a recent upgrade to the MapSource program it
>should include some new tools for editing tracklogs. You can use these
>to split your Saved tracks and eliminate the spurious straight line
>segments.
Excellent response, Peter!
I have encountered instances in the past that would appear to conform to
each of your descriptions.
You wouldn't believe how many times, and for how long, I have been
perplexed by this issue!
I have downloaded the latest version of the program, and will now set about
"correcting" those tracks.
Thank you so much, and best regards,
David
- Mapsource track points
- Garmin GPS
- 2009-05-13
- following a saved track
- Global Positioning System
- 2005-11-02
- Garmin Nuvi acting strange
- Satellite Navigation
- 2010-10-07
- Trimble Introduces Railway Track Maintenance and Modernization Solution
- Satellite Navigation
- 2011-02-16
- Track hire cars
- UK GPS Discussions
- 2010-07-02






> into it. Can someone please tell me what is happening?
> I have a Garmin 12Map. I routinely save track logs, especially when
> traveling in new places. I use the "Fill", not "Wrap", option. On the
> last trip, for example, I saved seven full track logs.
> What is strange, is that periodically I get an inexplicable track leg,
> sometimes several hundred miles long, between two places that I have been,
> (or sometimes where I haven't even been). This track leg is straight, and
> there aren't even any roads there, so it is impossible to have traveled it.
> However, otherwise, the actual track(s) that were followed appear to be
> accurate.