Page 3 of 5   < 1 2 3 > last >>
Bookmark this page: Add GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work  to Yahoo MyWeb Add GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work  to Google Bookmarks Add GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work  to Windows Live Add GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work  to Del.icio.us Digg GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work ! Add GPS Devices w Traffic Info   How Do They Work  to Netscape
  •  
  • Subject
  • Author
  • Date
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by TheDuck on July 18, 2010, 6:28 pm


Garmin can't fix the traffic information that is supplied by a completely
different company.
So it isn't Micro accurate. It is better than the radio stations telling you
about blockage which was cleared an hour or two before.



>> A lot of your information is incorrect. The traffic icon has a number
>> beside
>> it that indicates the distance to the trouble area. Also if the icon is
>> yellow or red the stretch of highway it indicates has a wide red or
>> yellow
>> shaded bar along the highway in the area of trouble.
> I do know the icon but the distance info on the icon is wildly
> inaccurate at best.
> For example, in my last long trip the icon showed "1.5mi" but I didn't
> hit the bottleneck until >20mi later.
> The yellow/red lines are quite good and accurate though, but you don't
> see those until you're within 1-2mi of the area.
> A better way for Garmin to do this is showing a zoomed-out birds-eye
> view of the entire route that includes all the bottlenecks during the
> "Heavy Traffic Ahead" voice prompts. But first they need to fix the
> inaccurate distance info on the traffice alert icon.
>


Posted by - Bobb - on July 19, 2010, 9:04 am



> Garmin can't fix the traffic information that is supplied by a completely
> different company.
> So it isn't Micro accurate. It is better than the radio stations telling
> you about blockage which was cleared an hour or two before.
I would note that in my frequent east coast road trips, as I incur 'ongoing
road projects' I always get a 'traffic slow ahead' message. I click the
traffic icon, then see reason is 'Slow from exit 111 to Exit 117 ' and yet
quite often there is no traffic. Or accident ... but it had cleared already.
I had always assumed the delay message was accurate, but once the detour was
going to be worse than staying on the road, so I continued - and there was
no delayat all. It's just a 'standard message they leave there until the
project is over'/ they get updated. For those, I would like a comment like
Slow traffic from 8pm-5am until Sept 1 , or whatever the specs are. ( I've
left such feedback at garmin)
I HAD avoided traffic for those warnings if there was a valid detour, and
then came to realize that they might be false alarms. Now when I see one of
those messages I don't know: is it real ? A few times I've guessed
incorrectly and been stuck in traffic .. if only I knew if I could trust it
on those "ongoing project" warnings.



>>> A lot of your information is incorrect. The traffic icon has a number
>>> beside
>>> it that indicates the distance to the trouble area. Also if the icon is
>>> yellow or red the stretch of highway it indicates has a wide red or
>>> yellow
>>> shaded bar along the highway in the area of trouble.
>> I do know the icon but the distance info on the icon is wildly
>> inaccurate at best.
>> For example, in my last long trip the icon showed "1.5mi" but I didn't
>> hit the bottleneck until >20mi later.
>> The yellow/red lines are quite good and accurate though, but you don't
>> see those until you're within 1-2mi of the area.
>> A better way for Garmin to do this is showing a zoomed-out birds-eye
>> view of the entire route that includes all the bottlenecks during the
>> "Heavy Traffic Ahead" voice prompts. But first they need to fix the
>> inaccurate distance info on the traffice alert icon.



Posted by Fred McKenzie on July 18, 2010, 3:10 pm


In article

> I get traffic on my 1490T but generally it doesn't tell you how far
> ahead the bottleneck is (one time it was 20 mi down the freeway! but
> it said "Heavy traffic ahead" as soon as I entered the freeway).

Figaro-

My 1490T provides considerable information. Each option seems to have a
sub-option when you tap on it. When warned of a delay ahead and
selecting search for traffic on route, an additional tap provides a map
of the highway area where the delay is located. It usually indicates
whether there has been an accident or traffic is just slow.

Traveling on I-4 from Orlando to Tampa, there is usually a warning of
delays ahead. Searching for traffic on route, you can see a map of
downtown Tampa with the exact area of congestion shown.

On my first trip with the new 1490T, there was an accident on I-4 ahead.
The indication was that the delay would be on the order of 5 minutes, so
I elected not to avoid it. It turned out to take about an hour to get
past it. By the time I realized my mistake, there were no more exits
between me and the accident!

Fred

Posted by Peter H. Coffin on July 18, 2010, 5:36 pm


On Sun, 18 Jul 2010 15:10:47 -0400, Fred McKenzie wrote:
> On my first trip with the new 1490T, there was an accident on I-4 ahead.
> The indication was that the delay would be on the order of 5 minutes, so
> I elected not to avoid it. It turned out to take about an hour to get
> past it. By the time I realized my mistake, there were no more exits
> between me and the accident!

Traffic information is subject to some delay, and accident-triggered
delays are the hard ones to guess at, since they're outside of
historical models of trafffic flows.

--
With a Dremel tool and a cut-off wheel, _everything_ takes a flat-blade
screwdriver.
                         -- Matt Roberds in the Monastery

Posted by - Bobb - on July 18, 2010, 3:18 pm



> My Google searches haven't helped at all. I'm just looking for really
> basic info about GPS devices with traffic info. 1) Do they route you
> around traffic problems or just warn you of problems? and 2) Where do
> they get their traffic info from? I know that they get it from an FM
> source but where does it originate? Does the info rely on someone in a
> traffic jam phoning in that info to some central clearing house?
> Thanks, Bob

For my 265T, free traffic subscription is broadcast over the air from NAVTEQ
( I can see that in traffic settings on my GPS )
http://www8.garmin.com/traffic/fm/navteq.html
and it doesn't cover every square inch of the country. Mine only covers:
http://www.navteq.com/rdstraffic/
I've driven all day in the southeast and not had the traffic icon appear.
Different offerings:
http://corporate.navteq.com/products_data_advanced_traffic.htm

http://www.traffic.com/
for NAVTEQ's big picture



Page 3 of 5   < 1 2 3 > last >>